Monday 22 December 2014

Winter Off-Season 1: Was the 2014 Race of Champions a load of nonsense

Greetings Internet, 

Now that the season has come to a conclusion, and the bonus points championship was decided on countback on race wins, the winter off-season begins. It is a time when often very little happens and when we sit around waiting for the ominous threat of Christmas... whatever that even is in this day and age. But in the midst of the darkness and cold that is the off-season when there is no racing going on the political and business wheels remain silently turning in the background. So while all that is going on it is time to take a look at what is supposed to be the grand finale of the motor racing calendar. In a world before Formula E existed, it was the send off before we all spent the winter months watching delayed coverage of LOORRS on Motors TV. Which in essence is a slightly mad, yet ultimately hilarious category where potentially insane Americans race an array of trucks and dirt buggies around small off-road circuits. It involves a lot of jumping, crashing and things of an upside down nature. 

The Race of Champions has been a stable presence on the annual sporting calendar and for the most part has been well received, pitting different champions against one another... but in many respects the 2014 offering didn't match up to its predecessors. Does that mean the event has lost it's edge, and does becoming champion carry the same degree of respect it once did. Well today, in an effort to put something new on this corner of the internet and to prevent me from forgetting how to put words into cohesive sentences (on reflection I fear that has already failed me) I endeavour to examine the 2014 iteration of the event. 


The Race of Champions



Last weekend (well 8 days ago now) was the annual end of year competition - the Race of Champions. An event that was put in place to answer to the eternal question that rumbles across the internet and across the tables in the pub... well maybe less so on the latter... is a rally driver faster than an F1 driver. Or can an Indycar champion trump a touring car legend - if everyone was placed on equal terms in equal cars, on a level playing field - who would come out on top. So many years ago an event was fashioned to sort that out - by bringing a collection of drivers, and a collection of cars alien to their native championship and let them fight it out. It is a strong concept, and one that has done well over the past few years being hosted in stadiums in Paris, Dusseldorf and London before visiting Bangkok. The 2013 event was also supposed to be held in the Thai capital - but unrest in the city prevented it taking place. So after a sabbatical the 2014 Race of Champions was moved to Barbados... sounds more like a swanky holiday for those who were selected to take part. 

The event takes place over two days - day one being an event to decide which nation delivers the best overall performance across the variety of different cars. Day two being the individual challenge, to find the 'Champion of Champions'... In 2014 the nations cup was not won by a nation and the champion of champions trophy didn't go to a champion... and that's where we have a problem. 2014 was a very poor year for the Race of Champions in terms of the strength of field - no current race winning F1 driver made the list, which is terrible. In fact the last F1 race victory in the entire roster was in 2003... sums it up really. Grosjean was the only current driver present, with Williams test driver Susie Wolf and former driver David Coulthard in support. Other categories were better represented Tom Kristensen from WEC and Le Mans fame was probably the most qualified attendant. Multiple Australian V8 Supercar champion Jaime Whincup was the most decorated representative for the touring car genre while Ryan Hunter-Reay represented Indycar. Aside from that Kurt Busch represented NASCAR and Petter Solberg arrived as Rallycross champion. 



Some strong participants in their field and in their home country - but the fact that there was no WRC representation, and none of the current F1, Indycar, NASCAR, WEC, WRC, USCC champions were present is a damning insight. Lopez, Solberg and Whincup were effectively the only 2014 champions at the top of their class present - and even then an argument can be made questioning the world status of the Australian championship. To rub salt into the wounds the field was padded out with junior formula drivers, Esteban Occon and Jolyon Palmer. Palmer might have a case as GP2 is - in theory the second rung in global single seater racing and therefore is fairly advanced. Euro F3 however is not... Occon wasn't even lumped in the 'future prospects' category, he was put forward as the co-representative of France. Admittedly Vergne was in Uruguay on Formula E duties, but no Loeb, Muller, Duval, Bourdais - seriously... Furthermore the fact that Germany, Finland and Japan/ Asia in general didn't field a team at all is rather sad. 

So having declared this latest iteration of an entertaining concept a bit of a limp effort, does winning it lose some of it's meaning - well frankly yes. The nations cup was effectively won by Tom Kristensen all on his own, despite being on a team with Solberg. The final was between them as team 'Nordic' versus Team GB (which may as well have been team Scotland) formed between Coulthard and Susie Wolf. Again one driver carried the team, resulting in a play off between Kristensen and DC - in which the Dane came out on top. The Champion of Champions went to Coulthard after he smashed Pascal Wehrlein, a token German representative who has scored one win and finished 8th in the DTM (behind four other Germans)... but was entered alongside Palmer as a 'young star'. I am all for surprise results and new talents taking to the stage - Heikki Kovalainen in 2006 taking the individual tile for example - but the difference between Heikki and Pascal's efforts was that the Finn fought through a much stronger field, and beat Michael Schumacher in the final at a time when the German was very much still a powerful force (even if Alonso had taken over the F1 crown that season). Couthard and Kristensen were easily the class of the field, across the very diverse range of machinery on offer, but I can't help but think that they had it a little too easy. 



This time around the venue was not a stadium as it had been for the previous few seasons, but a small national race track in Barbados which was modified to match the super-special rally format. Apparently it harked back to the earliest incarnations of the RoC event in which it was hosted in the Canary Islands on a part tarmac, part dirt rallycross style configuration. A strong range of cars was in use from high powered GT Audi R8's, VW rallycross cars, Aerial Atom Cup cars, Stadium Super Trucks and European NASCARs something to accommodate for most of the motor racing world. So while even if the drivers were a little thin on the ground, the competition machinery was suitably diverse. It might have nice if there was a section of the track that was covered in dirt as an equaliser between the race and rally drivers - but that would influence the list of cars available. For example the Audi R8 GT car would not work to well over some jumps and mud...

What is the answer to all of this then - frankly I don't know, mostly because I have no idea what the underlying causes were for the weaker list of participants than usual. Did the current set of champions just not bother putting themselves forward for invitation, or did the committee not invite them. According to Wikipedia only Grosjean and Kristensen were invited as the 2012 finalists from the last conducted Race of Champions event. I think that all major reigning champions should be invited - what counts as a major championship will ultimately be a source of discussion. But it should span as many disciplines as possible from Endurance prototypes and GTs, Rally, Touring Cars, Oval Racing, Motocycle Racing categories etc. Naturally would be difficult to integrate Motorcycles into the vehicle rotation for a RoC event but the competitors should be involved. The rest of the places should belong to certain invitational drivers - the likes of Kristensen, Coulthard, Robby Gordon, Yvan Muller and Sebastian Loeb who have competed successfully across a wide range of categories or have outstanding previous performance records. For example Muller is a former BTCC and WTCC champion but also has 9 ice racing titles to add to that, while Gordon has competed in NASCAR, Indycar, Dakar Rallies and now Stadium Truck racing. 

The nations cup side of things does complicate matters, because there is no guarantee that the list of champions is going to be neatly ordered into a series of pairs per country. Perhaps this would be a completely separate set of drivers - participating nations put forward their two strongest contenders, which may or may not be part of the individual competition. This also does need a much broader net to take drivers from - 8 teams barely scratches the surface of potential line-ups we could see. Of course a larger field, while it opens things up a little, would cause a problem with the TV and live event timings. 32 teams featuring two drivers would take an age to film and broadcast - even if it would add more credence to the title on offer. I suppose in that respect the Race of Champions isn't really an answer to that age old question we hoped it would be, but a bit of meaningless fun to round off the racing calendar. 

So in conclusion the 2014 Race of Champions was a shadow of its former self, or former selves as it should be. Maybe the two year delay is to blame, maybe it is the more remote location at fault - either way it won't go down as one of the finer incarnations. Both Coulthard and Kristensen do deserve recognition for their accomplishments considering both drivers have now retired from their respective fields and have still seen off any challengers. But the weakest part of the whole thing was their lack of competition and the lack of depth in the field. However, all of that only really matters if it was an event that really took itself seriously and I don't think it did this time. Being situated in an inherently relaxed part of the world out in the Caribbean may have contributed to that. If it is just designed as a bit of expensive elitist fun, then it was as successful as ever and the title is about as valuable as the little plastic football trophy I have at home. But as a means of deciding which category champion is the fastest, well by that metric it was in fact a load of nonsense - even if it was a mildly entertaining load of nonsense - and one that definitely needs more stadium trucks in the future.  

Tuesday 25 November 2014

Round 19 - Abu Dhabi 2014 - The Delayed Summary Review Thing

Greetings Internet,

Yes, I know it is now Tuesday, which is also not Sunday by a considerable number of hours. It is a shame to see four years of contributions to this corners of the internet peter out into a mess of inconsistency and poor punctuality, but these things do happen. It had been a chaotic couple of days which intervened and interrupted a once consistent schedule of publication and updates. When spouting irrelevant drivel into the empty darkness of this far flung corner of cyberspace - keeping on time is oh so important. I suppose there are hundreds and thousands of identical pages scatted the length and breadth of the internet doing the same thing I have attempted to do for these few seasons now and frankly do a far better job of it. The whole fabric of the myriad of posts and comments that have flowered and since wilted spawned from an initial spark of misplaced inspiration, from another series of parodied articles covering the 2008 season. I wanted to build something on that ground - something which blurred the fields of technical detail with comedic undertones and subtle humour. In 2011, it might have worked but now, here in 2014 it doesn't have the same edge to it that it once did and the individual posts become so much harder to compile and take hours on end to piece together. Mid 2013 saw the termination of the Thursday videos simply because four days of recording and editing reaped no measurable reward or indication of success - so in many respects it had become a waste of time, and the quality was a bit naff too. I have no idea whether there will be a 2015 edition of this corner of the internet, whether it is worth bothering any more, it becomes harder to validate it's existence when so many other people do a better job. Making a valid contribution in a domain inundated with content is an impossible task 

But before I consider dropping the final nail in this virtual coffin, I can't close the metaphorical doors without finishing the season since the final flag of 2014 has fallen. The reason why this post is multiple days behind schedule is partially a reflection on my dwindling capability to remember to do things, but also because I was out of the house most of the weekend. On Saturday I was hammering the keyboard to type out the final sentences on the post-qualifying document before scurrying out of the house to see a rival theatre group perform their end of year panto... An event that wasn't particularly motivating, you see I need now to spend the next ten nine days figuring out how to beat them (occasionally my competitive nature can take over). Then on Sunday I was having my ear drums obliterated at a rock concert and didn't get to go through the race coverage until midnight - so starting the multi-hour process of writing up wasn't on the cards. Yesterday I was at rehearsal for our performance, and after pushing hard to find ways of means of defeating the posh upstarts with their money and gimmicks it is too tiring to turn to the internet. Which brings me to today... Tuesday, I think.

By now the world knows what happened on Sunday - the racing bit that is - especially if you happen to live on this little rock off the coast of France. The news will have been full of the final moments of the race when the champion drove effortlessly across the line - hailing it as a monumental achievement. But in the end the battle was really won off the track, back in the Mercedes motorhome as it was parked in Belgium a long time ago now. Since then there have been snapshots when the tide has turned but those fractional moments in the face of an unstoppable onslaught only delayed the inevitable. I, the media and everyone else hoped that despite the seeming futility of it all there would be one final hurrah, something powerful and decisive to bring the season to an end. That grand finale moment when the entire cast are on finest form and the curtains close to rapturous applause... well as in life, these things rarely come to pass. Once again there was no titanic struggle, no race long tussle for that final victory - whilst the 2014 season has been a vast improvement on it's predecessor there has always been something missing. So much anticipation and suspense all fizzling out in the end. As the main protagonists danced a flat but finely choreographed routine all year, only drawing gasps of awe when one dropped out of step, the rest of the cast were left carrying the show. Abu Dhabi was no different.

The Race



As a sign of how far the series has fallen in the final rounds of a fading season a total of 18 cars sitting on the grid was the largest population we've seen since Russia. Even though Caterham had made a return, both Red Bulls were forced to start from the pit-lane because of an illegality with front wing deflection... I would make a joke about Red Bull and wings, but the internet has well and truly beaten me to it. Who knows how many will make it to Australia at the end of the winter. 

The race was over before it really began...again - the prospect of 53 laps of intense wheel to wheel duelling erased in about 20 metres. Lewis merely drove away from everyone and vanished off into the lead, Nico was second and everyone else was third. Except for the Red Bull cars who had to negotiate the underground pit exit before joining the rest of the field. Bottas didn't get such a great start and lost several positions - perhaps Toto had a word with Suzie to keep the Williams team away from the factory cars. One thing that has become apparent as the season drew itself to a close is that the drivers have become increasingly good at not hitting each other on the opening lap. Hulkenberg and Magnussen somehow managed to avoid contact in the first chicane at turn 5 - Kevin did have to run a little wide on the exit just to make sure. For some reason this did earn the Hulk a penalty for forcing another car off track... but sometimes the internal logic of the stewards office is a complete enigma. Sutil found himself on the receiving end of some contact on the exit of the hairpin, again Magnussen was involved as the pair brushed wheels. Neither car was severely damaged, but Kevin did ask the team whether the front suspension had been injured - McLaren couldn't see any signs of damage on the telemetry and the Dane carried on. At the back Grosjean took his drive through penalty, the one he earned at the very beginning of the weekend for power unit component changes

Red Bull, now fitted with legal front wings had a lot of ground to make up because of the long pit exit - but they easily picked off their first victim, Will Stevens in the Caterham. As we have seen since the start of the year, Ricciardo was the more active of the pair and lead the Red Bull formation as it attacked the runners at the back of the grid. Despite running with the weaker Renault engine some of the overtaking manoeuvres looked very easy once DRS was in effect. Daniel was able to pass Sutil and Kobayashi in one breaking zone, at the end of the first long straight - potentially this gulf in performance is why neither Caterham or Sauber have collected any points this season. Speaking of performance gulfs, of a sort, Raikkonen and Alonso were in a little battle of their own with the Finn in front and Daniil charging up his death stare for his final race in the Toro Rosso car. As Brazil demonstrated, Kimi has no real motivation to make things easier for his departing team-mate and the same was true this time. Raikkonen would adopt a defensive line and force Alonso to try the outside - but unlike a certain Anglo-German pairing the Ferrari drivers were more respectful. Once Fernando managed to get far enough alongside on the approach to turn 10, Kimi didn't argue the point and allowed the other red car through. The commentary teams hailed it as a great pass, when it wasn't really - Raikkonen knew that he was beaten and backed out. The Finn also failed to take not of a scary faced Russian who was waiting in the background. As Raikkonen's line was compromised by the Alonso move, Kvyat was able to capitalise and launch the Toro Rosso down the inside of turn 14 and steal the place. This was arguably a better overtake than Fernando's.

The super-soft tyres proved to have a very short lifespan - especially when the cars are running with a heavy fuel load, and thus the opening bout of pit stops begun. When we have early stops and a bunch of cars running an alternate strategy, starting on the conventional soft compound, we end up with strategies merging and cars in all kinds of positions through the field. This shuffling of the pack can lead to some interesting battle pairings - none more so than Alonso and Will Stevens. Fernando emerged from his stop behind the rookie in the Caterham, Will instinctively defended in the hairpin, easing Fernando wide. Stevens then drew alongside as the Spaniard effected a pass on the first long straight - for a brief moment the Caterham was able to out-drag the Ferrari miraculously. But in the end a Ferrari is a much better car and Alonso had far more braking potential in his car thus completing an easy pass. Fernando did get on the team radio questioning who this upstart was - but fair play to Stevens, it was a pass for position and he is well within his rights to resist being overtaken. Even if he is driving a Caterham, Kamui did the same thing when unlapping himself earlier in the year and scored bonus points for doing so. 

I hadn't mentioned the two Mercedes drivers in a while, simply because they weren't doing anything noteworthy, just driving away at the front - only Massa was remotely on the same pace in third. They made their stops and remained a few seconds apart - in terms of the championship this would suit Lewis fine, a win made Nico's position irrelevant. But a mechanical drama for Hamilton would being the German right back into play... but Mercedes are the most successful team, they wouldn't let reliability influence a race or championship deciding result... would they... The pit stop sequence did allow Felipe Massa to cycle through to the lead for a little while, by virtue of staying on track longer. Perish the thought of Felipe Massa being involved in a Hamilton title decider... there would be so much poetic justice if the Brazilian took a victory and denied Lewis the championship... revenge six years in the making. But Williams did have to call Felipe in for some new tyres and Hamilton and Rosberg went to the front. 

Staying on the tenuous link of delayed vengeance, we have Jean-Eric Vergne - ignored by Red Bull and under threat of being ignored by Toro Rosso for 2015 found himself under pressure from Ricciardo of all people. The Australian who stole his place at the top team was now attempting to take away his place on track as well. But as we have seen in the latter half of the championship, Vergne can be very feisty when needed, and probably resented the thought of Daniel overtaking him. Ricciardo attempted an outside pass, in the same way that Alonso did to Raikkonen, but Vergne was having none of it and held his ground. The Austrailian exited the chicane ahead, only for a little while, as Vergne spotted an opening and threw his Toro Rosso at it. He gave Ricciardo no room on the exit and forcefully denied his former team-mate. No sanctions were brought against Vergne, which made me wonder what on earth was so heinous about Hulkenberg and Magnussen on the opening lap. Like I said earlier, there are many occasions when the terms 'logic' and 'stewards decision' are mutually exclusive. On the following lap Ricciardo had a second go at Vergne and was more successful

With most drivers now cycling back to the positions they were in before the round of stops - barring those on the longer first stint - things began to settle down. Perhaps as it was closing in on 1am when I actually watched this it seemed to be far more inactive than it actually was. Heck even Daniil Kvyat's car got board and broke down - alas we were not treated to a reprise of the Russian's radio message 'I have no engine' as he pulled the Toro Rosso off onto one of the many escape roads. In this effective downtime much attention was placed on the time difference between Hamilton and Rosberg sector after sector, lap after lap - perhaps hoping to see the gap close, a potential precursor to a fight for the win. But those numbers were not closing consistently, Nico would gain a few tenths here, but lose some elsewhere. Occasionally there would be a gain of half a second, to which Lewis would respond and extend the lead once more. Both cars were pushing and moving away from everyone else - some of that down to the fact that Magnussen on a long strategy had a collection of cars trapped behind him including Button, Alonso and Vettel. A total of seven world championships all lapping several seconds too slow due to traffic. Attention was drawn back to the lead pair when the gap suddenly increased by 1.2s, replays showing Nico running wide on the approach to the hotel section and losing a lot of time. It was a tense phase of the race, waiting for something to break

That seemingly minor mistake for the German turned out to be a symptom of a far more significant development. Nico announced on the radio that he felt that the car was losing power, a diagnosis that the team confirmed moments later. It seemed like once again a Mercedes car was going to let it's driver down in a critical phase of the race. A development that has spawned a monumental amount of commentary throughout the internet in the days following the race (the only advantage of being this far behind schedule). So many arguments around the question of does this most recent failure make the Mercedes team-mates equal, and it is an argument I imagine will rumble on well into the new season. At that point in time it was Rosberg who was affected and his lap times started to plummet, losing on average three seconds to those in the chasing pack. The Mercedes confirmed that is was in fact an ERS failure - so Nico was suddenly 160hp down on everyone else. Rosberg frantically quizzed the team - looking for a solution to reboot the hybrid system but nothing was forthcoming. Of course because the ERS is involved with regenerative braking, the failure also compromised his braking ability and had a knock on effect of dampening the torque of the rear wheels. In short it was game over for Rosberg - the only hope of taking the title was for Lewis car to suffer the same problem and retire completely a la Montreal. In that race Nico dragged a car without ERS and dying brakes onto the podium while Hamilton retired... As Felipe Massa breezed past to take second, that hope looked increasingly unlikely.

The only distraction from Rosberg's increasingly slowing car was Pastor Maldonado - who, somehow, was maintaining his personal streak of not crashing into anyone was in a spot of bother. His Lotus must have collected some form of power-up on track because his exhaust was transformed into a flame-thrower - spouting a blazing trail of fire from the rear of the car. As much as it did rather complete an atrocious season for Lotus - the bright orange and yellow flames did look awesome under the floodlights. More worryingly however was the delay in getting fire marshals to the scene, admittedly the incident looked fairly contained and the fire was limited to exiting the exhaust but even so... Eventually a team of very ballsy marshals had to sprint across the track to get to the stranded Lotus to put it out - Pastor should have taken a leaf out of Kovalainen's book and found an extinguisher and dealt with it himself.  It may have been well before my time, but it did bear a scary resemblance to the Tom Pryce incident at Kylami where a marshal with a fire extinguisher was struck when crossing the track, neither party survived. 

Back with the race and there was a degree of speculation as to whether Hamilton was encountering technical difficulties too, because Massa was carving into the Briton's lead. Taking up to two seconds out per lap - the prospect of a Massa/Hamilton fight was exciting, shades of their many comings together in 2011 mixed with the final 20s of the 2008 season all rolled into one... But investigations in the pit lane revealed that this was not the case and Lewis was merely managing his tyres, and car, towards the end of the stint. He pitted and rejoined behind Rosberg's limping Mercedes - by virtue of not having a car that was under the weather Lewis just pulled out and drove past. It wasn't long before Bottas performed the same feat and Nico was slipping further and further down the field - 5th place was the minimum position required to be mathematically in with a chance. A position that he was drifting back to at many seconds per lap. On the other side of the Mercedes garage, the team informed Lewis that he might want to pick the pace up a bit in this final stint, as they considered Massa to be a threat in the Williams.

Further back Alonso and Button were having another strong battle, irritatingly the majority of which was not captured on television. Sometimes a hopeless title fight manages to trump a pointless actual on track battle. We saw Fernando pass Button on the second attempt after Jenson defended the first effort but outbraked himself defending the second. But we never saw Jenson retake the place a few laps later, because we were all to focussed on the ongoing conversations between Rosberg and the pitwall. Conversations that became more and more frantic, Nico demanding to know what position he needed to finish in and the likelihood of achieving it mixed with the technical developments of his failing car. Despite the hints of desperation there was a sharp clarity about Nico's interrogation of the team.

In the midst of all this Felipe Massa was now leading the race, as a result of Hamilton pitting earlier - more questions started to surface: could Felipe go to the end on this tyre set? Would a late stop for the super-softs set up a final battle? The dull middle phase of the race was starting to build into something with promise and a faint hope of a very popular finale victory for Felipe Massa. But as we all know far too well, desired outcomes very rarely come to pass. It turned out that Massa, like several other drivers was opting for a final stint on the faster tyre, rather than attempting to make to the end on the current set. It is a strategy that has been applied effectively elsewhere this season - Vettel in Austin for example made it work rather well. Both Williams and Force India drivers were implementing this procedure and appeared to be working out. Bottas was closing in on Ricciardo and Force India were working both drivers into the points. All of this was at the expense of Rosberg who was travelling in the opposite direction. Rosberg's team informed their driver that a top five might be possible if he could keep Hulkenberg behind... probably as a benchmark of relative pace - if he could find enough with the stricken car to match a Force India things might still be alright... It was a matter of seconds between Hulkenberg catching Rosberg and vanishing off ahead into the distance... Today was not going to be a good day for Nico, at least there were only 15 or so laps left of it to endure. 

With laps remaining becoming an endangered species there wasn't too much happening at the front of the field, Massa was closing down on Lewis with the faster tyres but it looked increasingly unlikely that he'd completely close the gap. Ricciardo's grasp on third place faded away as Bottas closed in an took that place away from the Australian - that said, Daniel was still having an almighty race on the cusp of the podium from starting in the pit-lane. Jenson Button found himself in another respectable 5th place, more reasons to leave him in the car for 2015. After blasting past Rosberg, Hulkenberg sat in 6th. Behind him however cars were on the move... well one car... Sergio Perez in the second Force India was mirroring his team-mate's strategy and reaping the benefits. While Vettel and Alonso were battling over the lesser points the Mexican was able to build a substantial gap to the two multiple world champions and improve Force India's points haul. 

As for Rosberg, well it was just getting worse - the car got slower and slower as the brakes grew weaker and the ERS failure remained. Mercedes asked Nico to pit the car and call it a day as he fell outside the points, but in a show of resolute defiance and sportsmanship he told the team he would like to continue. In the face of extreme adversity, he wanted to continue - even after he suffered the embarrassment of being lapped by the champion elect, Rosberg stayed on track. As we summised Massa could not maintain the charge he started when he exited the pits - the tyres wouldn't hold on long enough and the gap stabilised. So Lewis Hamilton crossed the line not only as race winner, not only as a strong contributor to a record breaking season for the team, but as a double world champion. The two Williams cars filled the remainder of the podium and Ricciardo delivered a mega drive to be so close to the podium after a pit lane start. Jenson Button finished 5th for McLaren ahead of Hulkenberg and Perez for Force India. The final double points of the season were shared out between three former world champions - Vettel in 8th, Alonso in 9th and Raikkonen in 10th. 

The Final Bonus Points Championship Points Winners of 2014

While the FIA decided that Abu Dhabi was worth twice as many points as any other race - the same does not work here and the standard points system will be applied.

  • 25pts - Daniel Ricciardo - Almost a pits to podium performance, in a car which doesn't have the advantage of the one Vettel used to perform the same feat previously in Abu Dhabi
  • 18pts - Felipe Massa - Gave Mercedes and Hamilton a lot of pressure in the race and did threaten to steal a win on actual car pace
  • 15pts - Lewis Hamilton - I suppose that winning a world championship deserves some degree of points based recognition
  • 12pts - Nico Rosberg - For having the will and motivation to continue, and despite being branded as cold and calculating was magnanimous in losing out in the end to Hamilton
  • 10pts - Jenson Button - Top five again with more racing with Alonso, wouldn't that be a nice pairing eh Ron?
  • 8pts - Jean-Eric Vergne - That fight with Ricciardo may have only lasted a few corners but it was brilliant
  • 6pts - Will Stevens - Has to be awarded a selection of points for having the audacity to defend against a Ferrari with a Caterham, and for bringing the car home at the end in one piece.
  • 4pts - Daniel Kvyat - Mixing it with the world champions including a great pass on Raikkonen before the car broke down
  • 2pts - Pastor Maldonado - Those flames looked brilliant in the night
  • 1pt - Fernando Alonso - Wins most amusing radio comment of the day when encountering Will Stevens, and is rewarded with a bonus point.
The Final Penalty Points Championship Winners of 2014

The final race of the season doesn't always work out for everyone, and for everyone else there are penalty points...
  • The Stewards - If Vergne's pass was a legitimate move, when forcing Ricciardo wide - how was Hulkenberg on Magnussen worse... especially considering it was in the melee that is the opening lap...
  • Mercedes - With all that money, and all that performance how hard is it to make two cars that work... seriously
  • The Opposition - I have to issue a penalty point to the theatre company perched menacingly at the top of this hill, mostly for existing, but for not being terrible... that is most irritating.
Looking ahead to... 2015

That's all folks, as they say. 2014 is all wrapped up and packed away in the dusty annuls of history, and those annuls will say Mercedes dominated and only when they messed up did anyone else get a look in. They would be right, unequivocally so but that by no means tells the entire story of the season we have all witnessed unfold since that early morning start in March (although for me it was the TV recorder that did the early wake up). There have been some outstanding battles along the way - Vettel vs Alonso in Silverstone, Force India vs Williams and Hamilton vs Rosberg in Bahrain and Vergne vs the world in Singapore. We've had cars punching holes in walls, sailing through the air and racing within millimetres of each other. A season with the tremendous highs of Bahrain, Germany and Canada - the calm inactivity of Sochi and the worrying lows of Suzuka. Of the back of such an undulating year of competition the teams now plough head first into the winter development race - striving not only to build better, faster machines but for some to ensure they make the grid in the first place. 

In 2015 we will have at least one new rookie driver, a new engine manufacturer and a new racetrack. With so much more yet to be decided, who will drive for McLaren, where is Fernando Alonso going, will Manor GP rise from the financial ruin of Marussia and make it to Australia and finally and most importantly when will we see Jules Bianchi recover and return to the formula one grid. 






Saturday 22 November 2014

Round 19 - Abu Dhabi 2014 - The Grand Finale Qualifying

Greetings Internet, 

One session remains, one day of competition to decide the title, and first blood was emphatically drawn in the final part of qualifying today - all through free practice (barring FP3) and most of qualifying the form was sitting on one side of the Mercedes garage. But form is only there to be broken and when the pressure was on and the times truly mattered that pendulum swung in the opposite direction and almost allowed a couple of drivers to join the party at the front of the grid. The tension and those sharp glances across the press conference table have set up tomorrow's race to be one of great expectations, but one that could easily end up being processional because the grid positions as they are would suit the championship leader right down to the ground. So in that sense there is no real reason to push for the win and risk losing everything for the glory of winning the finale race. But racing drivers have never been rational people.



Qualifying 

For the first time in the past couple of races the grid was back up to 20 cars with the return of Caterham through their crowd-funding campaign plus whoever stumped up the rest of the cash.  To cement their re-emergence into the paddock for this finale it was their rookie driver who took to the circuit first, and managed to avoid crashing into the wall in the underground pit-lane. I still find it impressive that in the many years the Abu Dhabi circuit has been in use, no-one has actually hit that barrier. Will Stevens emerged from the tunnel with the Force India of Sergio Perez - and of the pair it was no great surprise to learn that the Mexican ended up with the faster time. 

The rest of the drivers began to filter out the pits, and while soft tyres seemed to be the order of the day Williams were defying convention and sticking to the harder of the two options. With a degree of inevitability a brace of Mercedes powered cars breezed their way to the very top of the time sheet. Rosberg on the softest tyres was fastest ahead of Bottas on the slightly less soft compound, the difference between the two being over a second. Some of that being down to the tyres, the rest down to the fact that Nico has a much faster car, if not the fastest car. But there was on contender who could argue with that sentiment, and did vehemently and that was Lewis Hamilton - just finding a tenth over his German team-mate.

As this was Q1, the attention is focussed on the bottom of the grid - due to Caterham's return five cars were to be relegated in Q1 and Q2. Naturally Caterham would be firmly bedded into the relegation zone - Kamui retaining a safe gap to Stevens. But Will was able to stay within 0.5s which is quite impressive considering he was almost three seconds slower in FP1. Sauber and Lotus were fighting over the honour of avoiding spending the rest of the session sitting on the sidelines. For a brief period of time Ferrari was in the bottom 5, but easily moved up the grid, more so Raikkonen as Fernando lost some time behind Will Stevens in the final two corners. As each of the Sauber and Lotus drivers crossed the line they moved up into 15th place - safe for a few seconds. Vergne was eventually shuffled down into the equation but leapt up into 14th. The penultimate car to cross the line was Adrian Sutil for Sauber - to escape relegation, Grosjean was next but lost time in the final sector and lost out by 0.022s. 

Q2

It was Mercedes power once again that found its way to the top of the tree in the opening minutes of Q2 - as Felipe Massa set the benchmark time on a used set of super-soft tyres. As much as we would like to see something other than a Mercedes factory car sitting at the top, it is a little unlikely to expect the Williams to hold back the main team. So Hamilton immediately responded and set a 1:40.990 - many, many tenths clear of anyone else. Rosberg in the sister car only managed a 1:53 - 13 seconds slower than the Briton, because Nico locked up at the turn 8 chicane and had to take to the run-off area. After the error Rosberg tweaked the brake balance - moving it more rearward from 62% front to 56% on the front, because in the end locking wheels is more Lewis' trait. Nico's second lap was more productive, but he was still more than half a second behind his team-mate. This big gap in lap time left room for Williams to strike, Massa and Bottas taking 2nd and 3rd places ahead of Rosberg.

While McLaren wrestle with an ever increasing driver selection problem, their current pilots were trapped in the relegation zone without setting a lap. Both cars had left the pits but didn't finish a flying lap - although we didn't see it Magnussen reportedly made an error on his lap and decided to abort - possibly a result of flat-spotted tyres. Jenson on the other hand had encountered a far more frustrating problem - the team called him back to the pits, to which Button was justifiably confused and asked if there was a reason to abort his run. It turned out that the team hadn't put enough fuel in the car and he had to pit to top up enough to complete his final runs. With the car refuelled, Jenson was able to set a time and move out of the relegation zone. Magnussen was also able to escape relegation when he returned to the track, but late runs for Kvyat changed that as he took the Dane's place in Q3

Q3

Two sessions done, and two victories for Hamilton - it looked for all the world as if qualifying and ultimately the championship had been decided. But as we have seen on many times before - things can change. Both Mercedes drivers took to the track, Rosberg ahead of Hamilton... just like Monaco... but Abu Dhabi doesn't really present the same opportunities for a well timed yellow flag as the streets of the principality does. Bottas may have set the initial base time for the session, but Rosberg was on stronger form with a stronger car setting the fastest time of the day so far. Hamilton had work to do to catch up with that time - it appeared that he was on track to achieve that objective until the final pair of corners. Lewis ran wide in the penultimate corner and locked up in the final one and lost a lot of time to Nico. Round one goes to the German.

A short interval to change tyres later, and battle was resumed and it was a battle with very little room for error. Because Felipe Massa and Valtteri Bottas was were only a tenth of a second behind Hamilton, and on the final runs there was a chance that if Mercedes dropped the ball - a few locked wheels here or there - and that front row lockout would be in jeopardy. As in the first phase of Q3, Rosberg was the first of the Mercedes pair to leave the garage, with Hamilton a safe distance further back. Bottas came so close to disrupting the order, only 0.004s behind Hamilton in 3rd place. This meant the fight was between the top two as Massa ended his final effort in 4th place - ending the Williams threat. If Hamilton could knit all his sectors together pole position was possible - but Rosberg was having none of if, moving the goalpost further ahead of the Briton. Lewis had half a second to recover to take pole position - all of the effort in the world wasn't good enough only finding just over a tenth of a second. As a result Nico takes pole for the final race of the season, but his immediate rival is right alongside him, Williams couldn't quite help Nico's championship ambitions... but tomorrow is a whole new day.

The Bonus Points Championship Points Winners

The final qualifying session of the season, and while the FIA have decided to apply double points - here at Blog HQ, more logic prevails because each race is as valuable as all the others.


  • 10pts - Daniil Kyvat - Almost out qualified Vettel and well inside the top ten for the Russian 
  • 8pts - Will Stevens - First ever qualifying session for the rookie, and to be within 0.5s of Kobayashi is reasonably impressive.
  • 6pts - Nico Rosberg - After Hamilton lead FP1 and 2, then did the same in qualifying, Rosberg demolished Lewis in the end
  • 5pts - Valtteri Bottas - So very close to making it onto the front row and getting in the way of Hamilton's plans
  • 4pts - Jenson Button - As McLaren struggle to decide on their drivers, Button once more severely defeats Magnussen
  • 3pts - Kimi Raikkonen  - It isn't very often the Finn out-qualifies Alonso, but Kimi kept it on track when Alonso missed the chicane in Q3
  • 2pts - Daniel Ricciardo - Completely smashed Vettel today despite the German having more qualifying efforts
  • 1pt - Stoffel Vandoorne - Another alarmingly dominant display from the Belgian in GP2... tough times for McLaren with his hat in the ring too
The Penalty Points Championship

It has been a while since I did add something to the penalty points table, but here are a couple of additions in the final weekend.
  • The FIA - Have to receive a point for developing a framework in which a driver can be handed a 20 place grid penalty on a grid of only 20 cars. Romain Grosjean received four 5-place grid drops for changing engine components. Because Romain qualified in 16th, he will be stuck with a penalty in the race too, as unused grid penalties can't be carried forward in the final race. This system is made to look farcical when Sebastian Vettel replaced the entire power unit and was only hit with a pit-lane start, nothing compared to Grosjean's penalty. The FIA have ordered a special large print version of the rule book just to throw at the Frenchman...
  • Bernie Ecclestone - Deserves a penalty point for all of the ludacrous statements he has been issuing in the recent week or so. Claiming that the sport doesn't really need young fans simply because they are not rich enough to fit within the target demographic of the title sponsors... Followed that up with comments that the teams are idiots to slam the double points system as he removed it from 2015.
Tomorrow, the grand finale

This is it, the title decider one race to decide it all - Lewis has an important advantage over Rosberg and enough car pace to be safe in second place even if Nico storms off into the distance. It would take a bizarre set of events to see Rosberg take the title, and bizarre circumstances would make for a very entertaining race. It would take safety car interventions, mechanical difficulties or some on-track altercations to prevent the inevitable. But for some reason I can't really see Lewis holding back and allowing Rosberg an easy victory, and that drive and motivation could in the end be his undoing... Bring it on.

Thursday 20 November 2014

Round 19 - Abu Dhabi 2014 - The Grand Finale Preview

Greetings Internet, 

Many, many months ago 22 drivers sat on the grid in Australia as this season began. Since then we've seen controversies, political wrangling, more mad Bernie statements. Oh and a little bit of racing. But although there is only one more race left of this championship campaign - so much remains incomplete and undecided. Some pieces have started to fall into place in the days leading up to the grand finale - namely what Vettel and Alonso were doing. Sebastian, having announced he was leaving Red Bull some races ago now - didn't have a seat booked for 2015. A recent development sees the worst kept secret of recent times revealed to the unsurprised public. As we all suspected and as well all expected Vettel will be driving a Ferrari next season, alongside Kimi Raikkonen. Fernando has officially left the team and is going... well that bit isn't clear yet, like Vettel to Ferrari - the world assumes that the Spaniard will be sitting in a new Honda powered McLaren. However there are already two people in the McLaren stable, and somebody would have to be usurped for that to happen. Naturally this leaves Ron Dennis in an awkward position - who do you fire - the shaky but developing Magnussen, or the older but faster and more experienced Jenson. If I had the option, I'd keep Jenson and give FP1 sessions to Kevin - where that puts there rising development driver Vandoorne who knows. But this is why we need smaller teams on the grid to place rookie drivers, do you hear me Bernie...

Speaking of the smaller teams that had been absent from the past two events. Well, both of them had planned/hoped to be able to make it for the final event of the season. Marussia, despite closing the factory had all the workers on standby in case a deal was brokered allowing them to compete in the finale. Sadly this deal never appeared and Marussia won't be making it to Abu Dhabi. On a more positive note, this week we heard that Jules Bianchi is in a stable enough condition to be transported home to France to continue his ongoing recovery. Caterham on the other hand, asked the fans for help - well the proportion of the fans with lots of money that is - by selling off various things to raise funds. This crowd-funding campaign was organised and operated by the administrators in control of the company - so it did seem a little dodgy. But if you had thousands of pounds you could have bought parts from previous Caterham/Lotus (when they were Lotus) cars and driver clothing. This strategy aimed to raise 2.3 million from the supporters, and didn't complete that target, yet somehow the campaign was declared a success. 

So Caterham will be in Abu-Dhabi... which caused a second problem, Marcus Ericsson had terminated his contract with the team with immediate effect. Meaning he won't be in the car for the finale, effectively moving straight over to Sauber where he'll be driving in 2015. So Caterham needed another driver, Roberto Mehri is supposed to be their reserve driver, and Caterham have already shown they would rather use someone else when they sold Kamui's seat to Lotterer in Spa. Similar to when Lotus refused to allow Valsecchi to take over when Kimi went AWOL, so does Mehri get the nod this time... no. His name was mentioned in the list of potential replacements, a list which oddly also contained Alice Powell - that came out of nowhere. Mehri claimed he had a contract, or at least thought he did - but the drive has been handed to another Caterham junior driver (not that it usually means to much any more) Will Stevens - even though Will did sign up to be Marussia's test driver mid season. On balance Stevens isn't a bad selection, probably similar on pace to Mehri and faster than Alice Powell or a second effort for Lotterer.



The Venue

From the simple and effective brilliance of Interlagos we arrive back in the middle-east for the final act of 2014.  The Yas Marina circuit is neither simple nor effective - it is merely a device to show off the disproportionate wealth of this part of the world. Wealth that I suspect that paid for the privilege of being the final race and for the double points mess as well. From the air and the track side images it does genuinely look very impressive, especially as the light fades in the second half of the race. It is a colossal achievement of design, engineering and architecture with spectacular facilities on a staggering scale. From the colour changing hotel and underground pit exit it looks like it has fallen out of an arcade video game set in the near future. But does all this make it a good race track... well frankly no...

All the fancy LED bells and whistles can't cover up a layout that is lacking in many respects - there are some redeeming features but they are mired in too much repetition. The first sector isn't too bad - even though turn one is one of the many general purpose 90 degree corners shoehorned into this lap. The first one is reasonably wide and can be taken with some degree of speed, leading into a faster section of road. Turns 2-4 follow the only real element of elevation change on what is an universally flat piece of land. A section which saw Alonso and Vergne had all kinds of fun running out wide and bouncing over the kerbs without lifting... That's about it for the good stuff, for now, the chicane at turns five and six is both needless and pointless - one of the many examples of using many corners when one would do. However it still is less of a pain than the abomination stapled to the end of the Circuit de Calalunya... All it does is slow down the entry for the hairpin of turn 7, surrounded by towering amphitheatre of spectators. 

Sector two is composed of long straights - because Mr Tilke likes having some overly long straights in his designs - and to promote overtaking... before DRS swept in and made it a formality. For some reason - the first of these long straights shifts over to the left by a lane towards the end, before braking for the turn 8-9 chicane. This chicane I can live with - because you needed something to bring the straight to an end and offer an overtaking spot. It probably could have been a little more open, and there could be some grass to prevent corner cutting - but you can't have everything. The chicane exits onto the second long slightly curved straight - cue more DRS based overtaking before a corner comes up. At the end it seems someone got a little trigger happy with the corner painting tool in the track design software, sticking three corners at the end of the straight. There is no need for the 12-13 chicane, it doesn't add anything to the track and only causes more problems with track limits abuse... something I doubt we'll be spared this weekend. 

The final phase of the lap is all about appeasing the sponsors and corporate guests hanging out in the marina section. The first part of which isn't too bad - the two medium speed corners at 15 and 16 make lining up the braking zone for 17 more complicated. But all this does is position the road so that it goes underneath the hotel via two generic 90 degree bends. These corners give the track a nice talking point in form of a nice glowing building but are not really an interesting or worthwhile addition to the lap. After passing under another immaculate white, glass lined bridge the track approaches the final pair of corners. Following the same principle of the section of track from 15-17, a faster first corner leading into a slower second. The first part - turn 20 - will catch some people out as it seems faster than it actually is, while turn 21 ends the lap usually with a track limits violation. It is slightly odd that after the cancelling out of lap times in Austria and Silverstone, the track limit's onslaught has gone a little quiet of late. Even though Sochi and Austin have plenty of opportunities to cheat and the system wasn't brought into play then.

The Championship Duel

Well, two drivers are left in contention in both championships - the far more presigious bonus points championship and some other FIA world drivers championship... like that one matters. One of the main talking points coming into this weekend was the influence that the rather silly double points rule would have on deciding the title. In the end all it does do, is improve the odds that Rosberg has of stealing the championship from Hamilton. If the German wins, Lewis has to finish second to become champion - no cars can finish between the two Mercedes'. However on a day when no intervening circumstances have taken place - the silver cars have scored a 1-2 finish. So you'd have to think that only a mechanical difficulty or an accident would deny Lewis the trophy. Since rain is very unlikely, track conditions won't be the source of any intervening circumstances. A Nico Rosberg championship would require a very bizarre and exciting race... and would be a nice way to round out the season. I don't personally care too much who wins, but the most unlikely outcome is often derived from the most enthralling of weekends. 

Is there anyone who could get involved with the Mercedes fight on raw pace... well I severely doubt it - Williams will most likely be closest, but still only 3rd and 4th. McLaren, Ferrari and Red Bull should occupy the next set of positions. There are some rumours that McLaren are bringing a heavily developed version of their car to Abu Dhabi - at least for Friday practice. Potentially a legacy of the brief shakedown of the Honda engines in the break between Brazil and this weekend. That might place them immediately behind Williams, and clear of Ferrari and co, but that remains to be seen.

Caterham's return this time out means that Sauber and Lotus will no longer be fighting over last place. They still won't be on the pace of Force India and Toro Rosso ahead of them, but it is some consolation to be ahead of someone. I don't really know what Caterham are here to prove this weekend, other than their clear desire to compete which is most commendable, since their rivals Marussia can't attend. How this affects the constructors rankings is interesting, because although Marussia aren't in attendance they are ahead in points. Because if I remember correctly  (which is a rarity) a comment from Ted Kravitz suggested that the prize money from securing 9th place with Bianchi's Monaco result will not be passed down to Sauber if Marussia cease to exist. I suppose then by that logic, Caterham can't move up to 10th place by completing the final race. I suppose we shall just have to see how this one works out...

The Abu Dhabi GP isn't the most inspiring track in the world, but has managed to put on a show from time to time - 2012 being a prime example. We saw the perils of lapped cars as Rosberg launched over the back of Narain Karthekeyan's HRT after the Indian driver suffered an engine failure in the final corner. We may have fewer cars from small teams this season, but a complete rookie in the form of Will Stevens in the Caterham will be making his debut on the biggest stage. Tensions between the front two will be at their highest since Spa and while we probably won't be treated to a season finale on the scale of 2012 or 2008 but here's hoping this season concludes with something memorable.

Monday 10 November 2014

Round 18: Brazil 2014 - Review

Greetings Internet, 

Now, excuse me Brazil but I believe we ordered some rain this weekend, and I'd like to know where it is thank you very much. So because Interlagos was bathed in spontaneous sunshine the penultimate episode in this season came down to tyre management and strategy rather than raw pace and wheel to wheel racing. Even though we did get some of that along the way - just none at the front, but in fairness we have got quite used to that for several seasons now. Like Austin and I assume like Abu Dhabi coming up this weekend became less about the on-track action since that is more or less a formality, and more about the indeterminate politics of driver moves and team budgets. It seems like a deepening vein of hypocrisy is emerging at the front of the grid, and the TV figurehead is Christian Horner. Bickering about Mercedes doing what they can to hold on to their advantage, but complained endlessly when other teams questioned their domination in the past four seasons... I smell the rising scent of sour grapes... that is if I had a functioning sense of smell...

Today's race was unnaturally well behaved, drivers gave each other room - mostly - and I don't think there was any degree of contact at all. I think that over the course of the 71 laps only two cars actually left the track surface such was the level of consistency and control on display. Some battles did emerge but all in all it was one of the tamer races of the season - controlled by tyre conservation and pit strategy. Also the more observant of the readers - if in fact there are any readers - that there was no post yesterday. That was because I was a little preoccupied at the time and didn't get to see qualifying until 1am so didn't really get too much time to put in the multiple hours it takes to write one of these contributions. 



The Race

Expectations of the race did drop slightly as soon as the screen depicted a completely blue sky and bright sunshine - forecasts leading up to the weekend were for showers and rain events on each day. Somehow absolutely none of that materialised, it's like 2013 all over again where all forecasts of rain were lies and deception...

At the start of the race we were presented with an identical situation to Austin - 17 cars on the grid and one in the pit-lane. This time Adrian Sutil was the car missing out on the standing start, after the Sauber suffered a 'technical change' Monisha shrewdly not clarifying what the change was. But given how narrow the track is the field would still look fairly busy through the first corner. Alas it was all very uniform everyone seemed to make an identical start and the positions remained static. In turn four Vettel was passed by Kevin Magnussen which also opened the door for Fernando Alonso to follow through. Sebastian said after the race that he didn't want to turn in because in 2012 he did just that and ran into Bruno Senna. 

For the first stint a grand total of nothing really happened - because everyone was far more concerned with the soft compound tyres which were suffering in the heat. Pastor Maldonado was the first car to pit but out of the front running cars Felipe Massa was the first car to switch onto a new set of tyres from third place. But the local hero's shot at a podium took an early hit when he was pinged for speeding in the pit lane and received a 5 second pit stop time penalty on his next visit to the garage. Of course Felipe had a cunning plan to try and avoid that penalty, but we'll get to that one later on. As the sequence of stops continued, those drivers who started the race on the medium compound tyres cycled towards the front. As Hamilton and Rosberg pitted - Nico Hulkenberg ended up in the lead followed by Daniil Kyvat. Furthermore with such a small grid - and this early in the race a pit stop dropped cars a long way back. The Alonso, Vettel, Ricciardo battle had been dumped to outside the points positions. 

For Mercedes the deficit wasn't as severe - and their pace advantage allowed them to effortlessly overtake Grosjean, Kvyat and Hulkenberg will almost no resistance to go to the front. So despite qualifying demonstrating that another car could get within a few tenths of a Mercedes - in the race they were untouchable. Massa was keeping them just in sight, but had the upcoming penalty looming over his head dampening his faint glimmer of hope of taking on one of the factory cars. The second Williams of Valtteri Bottas was under some considerable pressure from Jenson Button - after the two cars pitted and virtually left the lane side by side. The Finn had enough top speed to defend against any DRS powered McLaren efforts. 

With the late stoppers filtered back down the order it was time to start talking about the tyres again and how difficult they were proving to be. Hamilton pointed out that blisters were appearing on his fronts, and Rosberg was encountering rear graining - not that he was initially sure what the car was doing. First he suggested there was understeer, and then corrected that to say it was in fact oversteer... surely he has been driving cars long enough to figure out the difference. Despite all these complaints, lap times were still improving so ailing tyres were making no difference. Lewis was still closing in on Nico, and the Red Bulls in a similar situation were still applying pressure to a struggling Fernando Alonso. The only car currently holdling out on the original tyreset was Romain Grosjean in the Lotus in the midst of the Magnussen, Alonso et al train of cars. Romain was visibly short of grip - powersliding out of corners and locking wheels everywhere - but the Frenchman unlike many others was willing to defend his place from the attackers. 

In the second round of stops is was double pain for Williams as Massa had to endure that penalty addition to his stop time, and Bottas had an equally slow stop as a result of some loose seat belts. This promoted Jenson to fourth ahead of the Finn and closer to the back of Felipe's Williams and a potential podium position. Up front Hamilton engaged 'Hammer time' mode after Nico pitted for his second stop - and pushed a little too much... which somehow was the team's fault for not calling the number of laps to push for. On the second lap of 'Hammer time' Lewis messed up in turn four and slid out across the run-off area. It wasn't too long ago that the tarmac run-off space was grass filled with puddles and ruts. So a mistake that could have lead to a damaged car and a loss of track position only cost a net seven seconds. That seven seconds did however prevent Hamilton from taking the lead of the race and ultimately the race win... but still could have been worse.

After Hamilton got back to the pits for some new tyres, he started peeling time away from Nico's lead - it was looking very much like Austin all over again. Would we see another half-hearted defence followed by Hamilton merely wandering off into the distance. Cars on the alternate strategy once more found themselves in the middle of the top ten once more - Hulkenberg being the lead purveyor of the opposite approach, this time hunting down Raikkonen who was considering jumping on the two-stop bandwagon. Of course Hulkenberg would have to stop again for the softer tyres in the final phase of the race - rather than let the Force India catch up Kimi was called in to pit - jumping off the bandwagon once more before it cost him time. However the Ferrari pit crew did that job for him with their inconsistent front swivel jack device, as the jackman moved the side the car dropped - as it did to Alonso in Russia - before the wheels were all attached. 

Red Bull were encountering contrasting fortunes in this middle phase of the race, Sebastian Vettel benefited from a helpful strategy call by his team to jump ahead of Magnussen and Alonso. This trio of cars found themselves carving past Daniil Kyvat whose tyres were considerably past their best at this point - as the Russian was on the same alternative strategy as Grosjean and Hulkenberg running the medium compound tyres up until the final stint of the race. As Ricciardo approached this particular group of cars one of the upper suspension arms on his Red Bull failed under braking for the first corner. The Australian assumed it was a brake failure as the suspension components are not usually visible from the driver's eyeline. As tyre strategies were continually shifting to favour one car or another in a particular battle we saw Hulkenberg attacking Bottas. On this season's form the Williams should easily have the beating of a Force India - even in this race Bottas held off Button before his slow stop cost him the position. The Hulk made a definitive lunge to the inside of the Williams in turn one - making sure the Finn had nowhere to go on the exit. As Valtteri scampered across the run-off Raikkonen picked up the slipstream and the DRS towards turn four. Valtteri defended but the momentum was with the Ferrari driver as Raikkonen switched to the inside to take the place. It was a sign that the tyres needed changing on Valtteri's car, but the stop was slow once more as mechanics had to clear debris from the vents in the front and rear wings on his car.

Another battle unfolding was between Magnussen and Alonso - having seen how defensive the Dane was in a similar duel in Spa things could get interesting. But then again Kevin was a lot more lenient in Austin, probably to avoid any more penalties for aggressive defensive moves. This time round the McLaren driver did close the door - gently claiming the inside for turn four, but ran wide on the tighter line and handed Fernando the position. Felipe Massa had a plan to evade any future pit-lane penalties... by stopping in the wrong pit box. Felipe pulled his Williams up to a crowd of waiting McLaren mechanics who were waiting for Jenson Button. The Brazilian had already served his speeding penalty today but this could be a scouting mission for the finale - and McLaren already have enough issues on deciding their driver line up without other pilots throwing themselves at the team. 

At the very front Mercedes were still having it their own way, miles ahead of Massa and Button. Hamilton had easily cut away the amount of the time he lost by spinning earlier in the race. The gap fluctuated as the pair meandered through the lapped traffic - even without Marussia and Caterham - lapped traffic still exists. Rosberg occasionally slipped into the DRS range of his chasing team-mate but the two cars were not close enough at this stage for Lewis to attempt a pass. Behind the two Mercedes cars, a long way behind that is, was the Force India of Nico Hulkenberg but once again it was tyres limiting his progress - starting on the medium compound meant that the German would have to use the softs at some point. As they were the more fragile tyre the idea was to delay that for as long as possible - this compromised his potential for lap time, it allowed Felipe Massa to close in and retake the final podium spot. Naturally this was to the grand delight of the local audience, whose appreciation was audible over the engine notes.

Kimi Raikkonen was starting to feel the strain of pushing his set of tyres in a long final stint as he dropped back into range of Jenson Button. The McLaren driver still unsure of his position next season went on the offensive with the Finnish driver. Kimi defended the inside in turn one as the two entered the corner side-by-side and held onto the place, but Jenson wasn't done quite yet and continued the battle up the Reta Oposta straight. Button got a better run through turns four and five and switched to the inside of the track on the exit. While Raikkonen was keeping an eye on what Button was doing Vettel joined in the battle and drove the Red Bull round the outside of the Ferrari in turn 6. Kimi saw the attack and didn't move across as it would have resulted in contact with the German and after that probably the barriers. While this was going on, Mercedes team-mates were now under a second apart - Hamilton occasionally pulling out of the slipstream just to appear in Nico's wing mirrors in the baking areas. Trying to put the German off his stride, but is wasn't working - if he wanted to take the lead, he'd have to do it by force. 

As the top two were standing off each other the same could not be said for a another set of team-mates as Ferrari had both cars running line astern and in formation. Conventionally the Ferrari team would instruct the car in front to get out of Alonso's way - even if that car is driven by Raikkonen. Kimi was very defensive, refusing to give Fernando any opportunity to take the place. It was suggested that Ferrari being unwilling to make the call to put Fernando in front of the other red car was an indication that the Spaniard will not be in the team next season. But at this stage of the year with so little confirmed, every action or inaction will be scrutinised for any hidden meaning. In the absence of any team-radio broadcasts we can't be sure what was going on, and in all honesty is was much more entertaining seeing them race each other. Plus of all the people who would be bothered about their team-mate I don't think Kimi would be at the top of the list. After a couple of laps of defensive driving, including seeing both Ferrari's two wide through the double apexed turn 6 - Fernando won the fight using DRS on the main straight to complete the pass before braking for turn one. 

With laps running out the battle for the lead closed to within half a second, faint hopes of another Bahrain style fight were emerging - but lapped traffic and an injection of pace from Rosberg added a few tenths to that. It did fluctuate slightly in those remaining laps, but Rosberg crossed the line in the lead, trimming a few points of what remains an unassailable lead. In terms of the championship it would take a mechanical failure or a severe error to cost Lewis the title - because there are no competitors on the grid that can prevent a Mercedes 1-2 if both cars are healthy and running to task. Rosberg can only hope that misfortune befalls Lewis because nothing else can stop him. The podium was completed by Felipe Massa, a popular result for the local crowd. 

The Bonus Points Championship

Again with a smaller grid of cars, handing out points is more difficult, but here are the winners from the Brazilian GP weekend.

Qualifying Results

  • 10pts - Esteban Gutierrez - On the weekend he discovers he no longer has a drive the Mexican almost makes it into the top ten for Sauber
  • 8pts - Felipe Massa - Local support translated into lap time for Massa, beating Hamilton in Q2 and close to the front row in Q3
  • 6pts - Valtteri Bottas - Like Massa spitting the Mercedes in Q2 is a noteworthy achievement 
  • 5pts - Nico Rosberg - Sets a new outright pole record for the Interlagos track and beat Hamilton in the process.
  • 4pts - Sebastian Vettel - Out qualifying Ricciardo and lines up on the grid as the lead non-Mercedes powered car on the grid
  • 3pts - Jenson Button - Effectively the best of the rest when considering the advantage of Mercedes and Williams have at the moment
  • 2pts - Lewis Hamilton - Tried hard to defeat Nico, kept raising the bar only to see the German clear it each time
  • 1pt - Fernando Alonso - Gets a point for his hilarious radio message as Romain Grosjean passed him in turn one in Q1
Race Results
  • 25pts - Felipe Massa - An incredibly popular podium finish, and was the only car within sight of the two Mercedes
  • 18pts - Nico Rosberg - Couldn't have done more to improve his championship odds, not that the minor points shift mattered too much. But showed Lewis who's boss today
  • 15pts - Kimi Raikkonen - Gets points for not letting Alonso by in the de facto hierarchy at Ferrari, and for his battle with Jenson Button
  • 12pts - Jenson Button - Another impressive drive, fighting with Raikkonen and capitalising on Williams dropping the ball slightly in the pits
  • 10pts - Fernando Alonso - Weathered the attacks of both Red Bull cars and got involved with a brilliant battle with Raikkonen 
  • 8pts - Nico Hulkenberg - Lead the race, albeit via staying on track, being the only non-Mercedes car to do so today
  • 6pts - Romain Grosjean - Gets some points for being one of the few drivers to put up a fight when cars on another strategy were moving up
  • 4pts - Daniil Kyvat - Was running second at one point from the back of the grid and almost took home some points
  • 2pts - Sebastian Vettel - Scores some points for his opportunistic pass to the outside of Raikkonen in turn six
  • 1pt - McLaren's Pit Crew - Get a point for not adopting Massa as he arrived in their pit box
Looking to the Grand Finale

In two weeks time the journey of F1 2014 will be completed, we shall have a champion and no real news on who is sitting in which seat in 2015. All under the cloud of double points, a situation which does give Rosberg a little more hope of taking the title, because Lewis has to finish in the top two to take the crown. In any other season with multiple competitive cars that would be huge risk, but this season with only two cars that can win under normal circumstances it is a different set of circumstances. Lewis only really needs to finish the race with a healthy car, if he does he'll either be 1st or 2nd because no other car can beat a healthy Mercedes without an exceptional set of events. In Hungary, rain and an inopportune safety car prevented a Rosberg victory and Hamilton started last. In Belgium the two Mercedes tangled, and in Canada brake failure crippled the silver arrows. Without mitigating circumstances a Mercedes has won, and most cases only reliability has prevented a 1-2 finish. 

Hamilton can only afford to be beaten by one car in Abu Dhabi, and in reality there is only one car that can do so - I expect a second championship for the Briton. But the bizarre set of events that would need to take place to upset that prediction will be well worth seeing and looking forward to.


Friday 7 November 2014

Round 18: Brazil 2014 - Preview

Greetings Internet, 

In some apparent rush to wrap the season up quickly the penultimate round is taking place this weekend in the more southern of the Americas - hosting the Brazilian GP. Even in such a small time frame various news stories have been circulating throughout the pit-lane... including the pit-lane itself this weekend. But before we get to that we have to look back at the fallout from the threats supposedly made by Force India, Lotus and Sauber regarding pulling out of the race on Sunday as part of a deepening row over the distribution of the sport's revenue. Bernie has accepted that there is a problem, one stemming from the contracts that were drawn up when the sport was in a different era - things have changed, but the financial conditions didn't. One of the concessions planned was to ask the larger teams - out of mutual compassion - to accept a smaller share to support the others. A theory which was naturally dismissed by those larger teams... because they don't want to risk anything that would compromise their advantage. This requires some form of long term solution to put right, somewhere deep in the core fabric of the management, something needs to change. Yet as we've seen with the sporting and technical regulations - the powers that be are not fond of making those decisions and changes, rather patching over the cracks with superficial repairs like DRS and the farcical business of double points. 

Aside from the financial chasm of despair, there are other rumblings in the paddock when considering driver line ups for 2015. Sauber have now confirmed that they will be replacing both Sutil and Gutierrez for next season - leaving the outgoing pilots without a seat at this point. Instead they have brought in Marcus Ericsson from struggling Caterham - because he has a lot of money, and improved a lot before the team descended into the abyss. Alongside the Swede will be Brazilian GP2 driver Felipe Nasr... and yes that is going to cause all manner of confusion having him and Massa on the same grid. Nasr also has a lot of money - but was arguably faster than Marcus in GP2 - this money comes from Banco Do Brasil, or something like it. The advantage there being that we might see a more colourful livery on the 2015 Sauber if they become a more influential team sponsor. With all this talk of driver swaps we are still no wiser as to the situation with Sebastian Vettel and where he is going. It is expected but not confirmed that it will be to Ferrari - but we have no idea what Fernando, the expected departee, is planning on doing. Almost every theory and guess under the sun has been suggested, from going to McLaren, going to WEC with Webber - or even an involvement with a hypothetical Audi F1 team or the Forza Rosso project which has gone very quiet. Some folk have even suggested leaving the sport altogether to run a Cycling team... yet the man himself has said that the end result, whatever that will be, will be considered the "obvious" choice... obvious to who, Fernando?...

The Venue



Anyway, back on track looking at the Interlagos circut hosting this penulimate round of the championship. Since the last visit, there have been some changes - changes made to the very end of the lap in and around the pit entry. The change has moved the start of the pit-lane further back around the final corner, and added a small chicane in the lane itself - I think the work is part of a larger plan to move the grandstands and the wall of that corner further back to allow more run-off. Especially considering the race is more often than not influenced by rain and difficult driving conditions. At present the corner looks unchanged apart from some resurfacing.

The main straight is situated in a canyon between two high concrete walls, where some of the grid sits on an uphill slope while the rest on a slight decline. In contrast to the mountainous climb up to the first corner in Austin, the track here falls away on the approach to the first apex. The heart of the first phase of the Senna 'S' is unsighted in the braking zone thus making it difficult to spot the turn in point. Judging the angle of attack through turn one defines the racing line for turn two - the second part of the chicane. Turn three is a simple acceleration zone in the dry - and a liability in the wet as rivers of water will flow across the track, as demonstrated by the wealth of cars crashing out there in that infamous race of 2003. If you haven't ended up in the scenery turn three exits into the first of the DRS zones encouraging overtaking on the run up to turn four. 

Turn four itself is a medium speed almost 90 degree corner, but the exit feeds directly into turn five which is an acceleration zone that opens up the previous bend. Thus allowing more speed to be carried through the exit, but the outside curbs and astroturf beyond can trap rainfall and spin a car back across into the inside barriers. Given that rain is projected for at least Practice and Qualifying - even on Sunday if it stays dry the areas beyond the white lines will be treacherous. After turn five there is a short straight uphill to Ferradura corner, a gently cambered and fairly quick corner bordered by a lot of painted curbing. The grass and gravel were removed many seasons ago but the paint remains which in the dry is a non-issue but in the wet it is a whole different kettle of piranhas. 

In the middle of the lap there is a sequence of three consecutive hairpins in the land grip forgot - the first one at turn 8 doesn't really have a name for some reason. But it has been the scene of a couple of opportunistic passes over the years if the car in front struggles on the exit of Ferradura. Part two is frustrating, off-camber and multiple shades of awkward - because the exit line for turn 8 doesn't quite fit with turn 9. It was one of the corners in the old fashioned F1 games that was a general pain in the neck - but now with more accurate simulation engines it is far more agreeable. Turn nine leads almost instantly into the braking zone for turn 10 - probably the corner with the best name of the season. Bico De Pato is the slowest of the thee hairpins and might offer a second overtaking spot if you use a little force - so there are plenty of options for some mad Vergne lunges. Especially since Kobayashi isn't here we need someone else to be a little bonkers under braking.

Towards the end of the lap the pace picks up a little starting with Mergulho a brilliant downhill curve which in the wet also suffers from rivers crossing the track. Rivers that caught Grosjean out in 2012 as he span into the barriers in another extraordinary Brazillian GP. Mergulho leads into Juncao which is probably one of the most important corners on a short and technical layout. Because getting a strong exit from Juncao defines the top speed all the way up the hill through the two final flat out kinks between the concrete walls before the start finish line. This straight plays host to the second of the DRS straights - which is a little irritating because overtaking in turn one was fine before all these gimmicks took over. 

The Form Guide

Well, all the forecasts suggest that this is going to be a rain affected race weekend at some point - with some heavy showers in time for Qualifying. So there is the potential for a rather jumbled grid for the race on Sunday, which in itself may or may not be rain affected - radar projections for the weather suggest it might fade by then. In any event, I expect that Mercedes will be out front no matter what the conditions turn out to be - but given the nature of the track the gap should be much smaller. Potentially Red Bull could be the closest contenders because the technical layout may favour a more mechanically grippy car with an aerodynamic advantage. Williams however will be stronger in the first and third sectors where straight line speed is far more advantageous. Ferrari and McLaren might be somewhere behind this group picking up on the lower points positions. We can expect Button to be a few places further forward if rain is involved.

Force India, Toro Rosso might be in with a shot of some points especially if it does rain because Vergne and Hulkenberg have proven to be very capable in the event of difficult conditions. Although Nico crashed out of the 2012 race when battling Hamilton for the lead in changeable conditions - so anything can happen. Sauber and Lotus will once again be fighting it out to be off the back row of the grid - and given the fact that both Sauber drivers have found that they have been dropped from the 2015 line up I doubt their enthusiasm will be at an all time high this time out. 

Like in Austin, Marussia and Caterham will not be joining the grid in Brazil but could make a comeback for Abu Dhabi in the grand finale of the season. Both of the struggling teams have been officially entered for the 2015 championship - Caterham remaining as Caterham racing, while Marussia revert to being called Manor GP - since that is the racing team that existed underneath the guise of first Virgin Racing and then Marussia. 

Overall the Brazilian GP has thrown up some outstanding races generally influenced by some exciting weather - which has hilariously increased after the race was moved from the start of the season to the end to avoid the rainy season. A season that ultimately provided the manic and very destructive 2003 race which finished under a red flag conditions and only two drivers were on the podium. Even then Giancarlo Fisichella wasn't awarded the race win until a few days later after it was discovered he passed Raikkonen (back when he was the faster team-mate) before the count-back cutoff. So if we could have some more of that - minus Alonso finishing the race in an ambulance of course - it would be much appreciated. Of course whatever does happen this weekend, the drivers championship is guaranteed to go down to the mental double points fiasco in the final round.